Suspects
- Jane Gibson (Pig Woman): local resident who claims to have heard the voices of the murderers
- Frances Noel Stevens Hall: wife of Rev. Edward Wheeler Hall
- Henry Hewgill Stevens: brother of Mrs. Hall
- William “Willie” Stevens: brother of Mrs. Hall
- Ike Gutman and Freddy: local gang members
- Julius Bolyog: not a suspect, but a Hungarian immigrant who came forward years later with evidence
-
